The Rollercoaster Love Life Of Lindsay Hubbard: A Summer House Dating Deep Dive

For fans of Bravo's hit reality series Summer House, few cast members have captivated audiences quite like Lindsay Hubbard. Known for her fiery personality, unwavering loyalty to her friends, and, perhaps most notably, her tumultuous romantic journey, Lindsay's dating life has been a constant source of headlines and water cooler conversations. From highly publicized engagements to private new beginnings, her quest for love has unfolded largely in the public eye, offering a candid look at the challenges and triumphs of dating within the unique world of reality television.

This article delves into the intricate web of Lindsay Hubbard's romantic history, drawing insights from recent updates and past revelations. We'll explore her most significant relationships, the dramatic twists and turns, and how her perspective on love has evolved amidst the Hamptons' summer drama.

The Highly Publicized Carl Radke Saga

It's impossible to discuss Lindsay Hubbard's dating life without immediately turning to Carl Radke. Their relationship, or rather, their series of relationships, has been a central narrative of Summer House since its inception. Their broken engagement alone made a lot of headlines, but it was just one chapter in a long, complicated story.

From Friends to Fiancés (and Back?)

Carl and Lindsay reportedly met for the first time in 2016 while they were filming the first season of Summer House, which eventually aired in January 2017. From those early days, their chemistry was undeniable, often blurring the lines between platonic friendship and romantic interest. This wasn't the first time the two had dated, though an attempt three years prior to a significant rekindling also occurred, showcasing their enduring connection.

Over the seasons, viewers watched as Lindsay and Carl navigated an on-again, off-again dynamic, sparking constant speculation about their relationship status. Finally, after years of friendship and flirtation, they officially confirmed their relationship, with Lindsay telling Page Six, "We’re definitely dating!" This led to a significant milestone: their engagement in August 2022. It seemed like the fairytale ending fans had hoped for. However, weeks before they were set to walk down the aisle, their wedding was called off, sending shockwaves through the Bravo community and leaving many, including Lindsay, feeling blindsided.

Navigating the Aftermath

The aftermath of the Carl Radke split was undoubtedly a difficult period for Lindsay. The highly publicized breakup meant she had to process her heartbreak in the glare of the spotlight. During the Summer House season 8 reunion, Hubbard confirmed she was dating a “wonderful man” after she and her costar Carl Radke called off their engagement in August. It looked like Summer House star Lindsay Hubbard was off the market! Following her highly publicized split from co-star Carl Radke, Lindsay jumped back into the dating scene, demonstrating her resilience and unwavering belief in finding love.

A New Chapter: The Turner Kufe Relationship

Following the emotional upheaval of her breakup with Carl, Lindsay embarked on a new, notably more private, romantic journey with Turner Kufe. This relationship marked a significant shift in how Lindsay approached sharing her personal life with the public.

A Private Romance Emerges

Hubbard, 38, and Kufe started dating in January 2024, though details about their initial connection were minimal. He, apparently, doesn’t like the spotlight, which explains why Turner hasn’t appeared on Summer House. Lindsay also explained this in an interview with StyleCaster, stating, "We started dating a year ago. At that point, you're trying to see if..." This desire for privacy was a stark contrast to her previous high-profile relationships, particularly with Carl. Viewers got a glimpse into this new phase when pregnant Lindsay Hubbard told Danielle Olivera in the Summer House season 9 trailer that she and her boyfriend didn’t live together despite her pregnancy.

Six months into their relationship and days after confirming she’s pregnant, the 37-year-old Summer House cast member, who split from former fiance Carl Radke in August, was navigating a new reality. Now, Lindsay was keeping her dating life private, with only minimal details given about her mystery boyfriend, who was later revealed to be Turner Kufe.

Parenthood and a "Pause"

The biggest news from this chapter was the welcoming of their first child, daughter Gemma, in December. This joyous event brought a new dimension to Lindsay's life, shifting her focus significantly. However, shortly after welcoming a baby girl together, Summer House star Lindsay Hubbard and boyfriend Turner Kufe broke up. Lindsay announced her split from Turner Kufe during the Summer House season 9 reunion, clarifying that they had put their "romantic relationship on pause."

This revelation came as a surprise to many, especially after the excitement of the baby's arrival. The Summer House mom's rare confession about her baby daddy came in a sneak peek at the Season 9 finale, where she admitted, "If I didn't get pregnant, I don't know if we would’ve stayed together." This candid statement offered a glimpse into the complexities of their relationship. Despite the romantic pause, as of early June 2025, Lindsay and Turner continue to co-parent closely, sharing responsibilities for Gemma. They attend doctor appointments together and divide childcare, showing a mature approach to their changed relationship dynamic.

Beyond Carl and Turner: Other Bravo Romances

While Carl and Turner have been Lindsay's most significant public relationships, it isn’t the only time she’s dated within the Bravo family. The Hamptons house has always been a hotbed for romance, and Lindsay has certainly been part of that trend.

Dating Within the "Bravo Family"

Her history includes brief romantic connections that have either been hinted at or briefly explored on the show. For instance, according to a first look at the Summer House Season 6 premiere, Lindsay came into the house "casually dating" Jason. There was also a moment when the pair were seen spending Easter together with Luke's Summer House costar Lindsay, though the picture was later deleted, suggesting a brief romance with the model. Carl Radke himself sparked romance rumors with Southern Charm’s Venita Aspen, as Austen Kroll and Rodrigo Reyes ‘liked’ a post speculating they’re dating after Venita and Carl were seen together, highlighting the interconnectedness of the Bravo universe.

The show's environment often leads to inter-cast relationships, and Lindsay's journey is a prime example of this. What happens in the Hamptons rarely stays there - at least when it comes to the cast of Summer House and their romances. Other cast members like Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover, or Jesse Solomon and Ciara Miller, also navigate their relationships under the public eye, underscoring the unique dating landscape of reality TV.

Lindsay's Evolving Perspective on Love

Through all the ups and downs, Lindsay Hubbard's perspective on love and dating has evidently matured. The experiences, particularly becoming a mother, have reshaped her priorities and how she approaches future relationships.

After welcoming Gemma and navigating the complexities of co-parenting, dating is understandably the last thing on Lindsay's mind at times. However, Lindsay Hubbard will never stop searching for her soulmate. In fact, the Summer House star is sharing an optimistic update on her love life nine months after her ex-fiancé Carl. She's focused on her daughter but remains hopeful for her romantic future, suggesting that while the immediate focus is on motherhood, the desire for a deep connection remains.

She has also shared insights into her dating preferences, revealing her "red flags in a date" during interviews, showcasing a clearer understanding of what she seeks and avoids in a partner. This self-awareness, coupled with her newfound role as a mother, points towards a more selective and intentional approach to dating moving forward.

Summary

Lindsay Hubbard's journey through love on Summer House has been nothing short of a captivating narrative. From her long, complicated history with Carl Radke, culminating in a dramatic broken engagement, to her more private and ultimately paused relationship with Turner Kufe, which brought her the joy of motherhood with daughter Gemma, Lindsay has experienced the full spectrum of romantic highs and lows. Her willingness to jump back into the dating scene, her candidness about her struggles, and her evolving perspective on privacy and priorities have made her one of the most relatable figures on reality television. While her current focus is on co-parenting Gemma and navigating this new chapter, Lindsay remains optimistic about finding her soulmate, continuing her quest for lasting love on her own terms.